Pairing amplification induced by nonadiabatic effects on the electron-phonon interaction throughout the BCS-BEC crossover

Midei G., Furutani K., Salasnich L., Perali A.

Furutani K., Midei G., Perali A., Salasnich L.

Shi T., Zhang W., Sa de Melo C.

Abstract We discuss standard and tighter upper bounds on the critical temperature T c of two-dimensional superfluids and superconductors versus particle density n or filling factor ν for continuum and lattice systems from the Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) to the Bose regime. We consider only one-band Hamiltonians, where the transition from the normal to the superfluid (superconducting) phase is governed by the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) mechanism of vortex-antivortex binding, such that a direct relation between the superfluid density tensor and T c exists. The standard critical temperature upper bound T c up 1 is obtained from the Ferrell-Glover-Tinkham sum rule for the optical conductivity, which constrains the superfluid density tensor components. We demonstrate that it is imperative to consider at least the full effect of phase fluctuations of the order parameter for superfluidity (superconductivity) and use the renormalization group to obtain the phase-fluctuation critical temperature T c θ , a much tighter bound to the critical temperature supremum than T c up 1 over a wide range of densities or filling factors. We also discuss a fundamental difference between superfluids and superconductors in regards to the vortex core energy dependence on density. Going beyond phase fluctuations, we note that theories including modulus fluctuations of the order parameter or particle-hole fluctuations valid throughout the BCS-Bose evolution are still lacking, but the inclusion of these fluctuations can only produce a critical temperature that is lower than T c θ and thus produce an even tighter bound to the critical temperature supremum. We conclude by indicating that if the measured critical temperature exceeds T c θ in experiments involving two-dimensional single-band systems, then a non-BKT mechanism must be invoked to describe the superfluid (superconducting) transition.

Sá de Melo C.A., Van Loon S.

We review aspects of the evolution from Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) in two dimensions, which have now become relevant in systems with low densities, such as gated superconductors Li xZrNCl, magic-angle twisted trilayer graphene, FeSe, FeSe1− xS x, and ultracold Fermi superfluids. We emphasize the important role played by chemical potentials in determining crossovers or topological quantum phase transitions during the BCS–BEC evolution in one-band and two-band superfluids and superconductors. We highlight that crossovers from BCS to BEC occur for pairing in nonnodal s-wave channels, whereas topological quantum phase transitions, in which the order parameter symmetry does not change, arise for pairing in any nodal higher angular momentum channels, such as d-wave. We conclude by discussing a few open questions regarding the BCS-to-BEC evolution in 2D, including modulus fluctuations of the order parameter, tighter upper bounds on critical temperatures, and the exploration of lattice effects in two-band superconductors and superfluids.

Cappelluti E., Grimaldi C., Pietronero L.

The very concept of high-Tc superconductivity has originated from the discovery of superconductivity in copper oxides by Bednorz and Müller in 1986. Soon after their discovery, cuprates were recognized as undoubtedly complex and radically unconventional superconducting materials, and research to understand the origin of superconducting phase has since then mainly focused on the strong-correlation aspects of these compounds, whereas the role of the electron–phonon coupling has been mostly ignored by much of the scientific community. Nowadays, however, thanks also to the steady later research of K.A. Müller, the presence of a relevant role of the electron–phonon coupling, in a unconventional scenario, has been assessed. Due to the small carrier concentration, and hence to the small Fermi energies, one of the concepts that needs to be revised in these compounds is the assumption of adiabaticity. In this contribution we summarize the main directions followed in this field for defining a microscopic theory of superconductivity in the nonadiabatic regime. The differences of such analysis with respect to a polaronic scenario are also discussed, as are some complementary paths of investigation of the complex many-body electron–phonon problem in different physical regimes.

Link M., Gao K., Kell A., Breyer M., Eberz D., Rauf B., Köhl M.

An artificial neural network is used to determine the phase diagram of strongly correlated fermions across the BCS-BEC crossover, revealing a maximum in the critical temperature at the bosonic side.

Midei G., Perali A.

Two-band electronic structures with a valence and a conduction band separated by a tunable energy gap and with pairing of electrons in different channels can be relevant to investigate the properties of two-dimensional multiband superconductors and electron-hole superfluids, such as monolayer FeSe, recently discovered superconducting bilayer graphene, and double-bilayer graphene electron-hole systems. This electronic configuration also allows us to study the coexistence of superconductivity and charge-density waves in connection with underdoped cuprates and transition metal dichalcogenides. By using a mean-field approach to study the system mentioned above, we have obtained numerical results for superconducting gaps, chemical potential, condensate fractions, coherence lengths, and superconducting mean-field critical temperature, considering a tunable band gap and different fillings of the conduction band, for a parametric choice of the pairing interactions. By tuning these quantities, the electrons redistribute among valence and conduction band in a complex way, leading to a new physics with respect to single-band superconductors, such as density-induced and band-selective BCS-BEC crossover, quantum phase transitions, and hidden criticalities. At finite temperature, this phenomenon is also responsible for the nonmonotonic behavior of the superconducting gaps resulting in a superconducting-normal state reentrant transition, without the need of disorder or magnetic effects.

Zhong Y., Li S., Liu H., Dong Y., Aido K., Arai Y., Li H., Zhang W., Shi Y., Wang Z., Shin S., Lee H.N., Miao H., Kondo T., Okazaki K.

AbstractIn crystalline materials, electron-phonon coupling (EPC) is a ubiquitous many-body interaction that drives conventional Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer superconductivity. Recently, in a new kagome metal CsV3Sb5, superconductivity that possibly intertwines with time-reversal and spatial symmetry-breaking orders is observed. Density functional theory calculations predicted weak EPC strength, λ, supporting an unconventional pairing mechanism in CsV3Sb5. However, experimental determination of λ is still missing, hindering a microscopic understanding of the intertwined ground state of CsV3Sb5. Here, using 7-eV laser-based angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy and Eliashberg function analysis, we determine an intermediate λ=0.45–0.6 at T = 6 K for both Sb 5p and V 3d electronic bands, which can support a conventional superconducting transition temperature on the same magnitude of experimental value in CsV3Sb5. Remarkably, the EPC on the V 3d-band enhances to λ~0.75 as the superconducting transition temperature elevated to 4.4 K in Cs(V0.93Nb0.07)3Sb5. Our results provide an important clue to understand the pairing mechanism in the kagome superconductor CsV3Sb5.

Dee P.M., Cohen-Stead B., Johnston S., Hirschfeld P.J.

In a recent work by Schrodi et al. [Phys. Rev. B 104, L140506 (2021)], the authors find an unconventional superconducting state with a sign-changing order parameter using the Migdal-Eliashberg theory, including the first vertex correction. This unconventional solution arises despite using an isotropic bare electron-phonon coupling in the Hamiltonian. We examine this claim using hybrid quantum Monte Carlo for a single-band Holstein model with a cuprate-like noninteracting band structure and identical parameters to Schrodi et al. Our Monte Carlo results for these parameters suggest that unconventional pairing correlations do not exceed their noninteracting values at any carrier concentration we have checked. Instead, strong charge-density-wave correlations persist at the lowest accessible temperatures for dilute and nearly half-filled bands. Lastly, we present arguments for how vertex-corrected Migdal-Eliashberg calculation schemes can lead to uncontrolled results in the presence of Fermi surface nesting.

Scazzola A., Amaricci A., Capone M.

We study the interplay between electron-electron interaction and a Jahn-Teller phonon coupling in a two-orbital Hubbard model. We demonstrate that the e-ph interaction coexists with the Mott localization driven by the Hubbard repulsion $U$, but it competes with the Hund's coupling $J$. This interplay leads to two spectacularly different Mott insulators, a standard high-spin Mott insulator with frozen phonons which is stable when the Hund's coupling prevails, and a low-spin Mott-bipolaronic insulator favored by phonons, where the characteristic features of Mott insulators and bipolarons coexist. The two phases are separated by a sharp boundary along which an intriguing intermediate solution emerges as a kind of compromise between the two solutions.

Shi Y., Zhang W., Sá de Melo C.A.

Abstract We show that in two-band s-wave superfluids it is possible to induce quantum phase transitions (QPTs) by tuning intraband and interband s-wave interactions, in sharp contrast to single-band s-wave superfluids, where only a crossover between Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) and Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) superfluidity occurs. For non-zero interband and attractive intraband interactions, we demonstrate that the ground state has always two interpenetrating superfluids possessing three spectroscopically distinct regions where pairing is qualitatively different: I) BCS pairing in both bands (BCS-BCS), II) BCS pairing in one band and BEC pairing in the other (BCS-BEC), and III) Bose pairing in both bands (BEC-BEC). Furthermore, we show that by fine tuning the interband interactions to zero one can induce QPTs in the ground state between three distinct superfluid phases. There are two phases where only one band is superfluid (S 1 or S 2), and one phase where both bands are superfluid , a situation which is absent in one-band s-wave systems. Lastly, we suggest that these crossovers and QPTs may be observed in multi-component systems such as 6Li, 40K, 87Sr, and 173Yb.

Schrodi F., Oppeneer P.M., Aperis A.

Unconventional superconductivity is commonly linked to electronic pairing mechanisms, since it is believed that the conventional electron-phonon interaction (EPI) cannot cause sign-changing superconducting gap symmetries. Here, we show that this common understanding needs to be revised when one considers a more elaborate theory of electron-phonon superconductivity beyond standard approximations. We selfconsistently solve the full-bandwidth, anisotropic Eliashberg equations including vertex corrections beyond Migdal's approximation assuming the usual isotropic EPI for cuprate, Fe-based and heavy-fermion superconductors with nested Fermi surfaces. In case of the high-$T_c$ cuprates we find a $d$-wave order parameter, as well as a nematic state upon increased doping. For Fe-based superconductors, we obtain $s_{\pm}$ gap symmetry, while for heavy-fermion CeCoIn$_5$ we find unconventional $d$-wave pairing. These results provide a proof-of-concept that EPI cannot be excluded as a mediator of unconventional and of high-$T_c$ superconductivity.

Wu X., Schwemmer T., Müller T., Consiglio A., Sangiovanni G., Di Sante D., Iqbal Y., Hanke W., Schnyder A.P., Denner M.M., Fischer M.H., Neupert T., Thomale R.

The recent discovery of AV_{3}Sb_{5} (A=K,Rb,Cs) has uncovered an intriguing arena for exotic Fermi surface instabilities in a kagome metal. Among them, superconductivity is found in the vicinity of multiple van Hove singularities, exhibiting indications of unconventional pairing. We show that the sublattice interference mechanism is central to understanding the formation of superconductivity in a kagome metal. Starting from an appropriately chosen minimal tight-binding model with multiple van Hove singularities close to the Fermi level for AV_{3}Sb_{5}, we provide a random phase approximation analysis of superconducting instabilities. Nonlocal Coulomb repulsion, the sublattice profile of the van Hove bands, and the interaction strength turn out to be the crucial parameters to determine the preferred pairing symmetry. Implications for potentially topological surface states are discussed, along with a proposal for additional measurements to pin down the nature of superconductivity in AV_{3}Sb_{5}.

Choi Y.W., Choi H.J.

Graphene moiré superlattices are outstanding platforms to study correlated electron physics and superconductivity with exceptional tunability. However, robust superconductivity has been measured only in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MA-TBG) and magic-angle twisted trilayer graphene (MA-TTG). The absence of a superconducting phase in certain moiré flat bands raises a question on the superconducting mechanism. In this work, we investigate electronic structure and electron-phonon coupling in graphene moiré superlattices based on atomistic calculations. We show that electron-phonon coupling strength λ is dramatically different among graphene moiré flat bands. The total strength λ is very large (λ>1) for MA-TBG and MA-TTG, both of which display robust superconductivity in experiments. However, λ is an order of magnitude smaller in twisted double bilayer graphene (TDBG) and twisted monolayer-bilayer graphene (TMBG) where superconductivity is reportedly rather weak or absent. We find that the Bernal-stacked layers in TDBG and TMBG induce sublattice polarization in the flat-band states, suppressing intersublattice electron-phonon matrix elements. We also obtain the nonadiabatic superconducting transition temperature T_{c} that matches well with the experimental results. Our results clearly show a correlation between strong electron-phonon coupling and experimental observations of robust superconductivity.

Nakagawa Y., Kasahara Y., Nomoto T., Arita R., Nojima T., Iwasa Y.

Inducing a crossover In conventional superconductors, the electron pairs responsible for superconductivity are large and overlapping. Starting from this so-called Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) limit, increasing interactions can set the system on a path of crossover to the opposite limit of small, tightly bound electron pairs that undergo Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC). Nakagawa et al. intercalated lithium ions into the insulating material zirconium nitride chloride, varying the carrier density across a large range (see the Perspective by Randeria). This induced superconductivity and enabled the system to enter the crossover regime between the BCS and BEC limits. Science , this issue p. 190 ; see also p. 132