Benchmarking of Pre- and Post-Quantum Group Encryption Schemes with Focus on IoT

In the next few years, both the number of IoT devices and the performance of quantum computers will increase. Both technologies pose a challenge to our current crypto-strategies. Therefore, post-quantum n-to-n communication encryption is a crucial field of research. Here, the development of new schemes and the analysis, and comparison of existing schemes is necessary. However, current work only investigates the performance of post-quantum schemes only for 1-to-1 communication. Therefore, in this paper, we analyze existing post-quantum schemes concerning n-to-n communication and compare them with pre-quantum schemes. Our results show that the pre-quantum schemes perform better regarding computation times than the post-quantum schemes, but the differences are sometimes only marginal. However, these marginal differences in computation times lead to the lower energy efficiency of the post-quantum schemes. In terms of features, there is no difference between both scheme classes. We show that the post-quantum schemes require unicast, whereas some pre-quantum schemes also support broadcast. Deciding whether to use pre- or post-quantum schemes for n-to-n encryption in IoT use cases depends on (i) whether energy efficiency is essential – e.g., in case of limited power supply – and (ii) whether unicast or broadcast is available.