United European Gastroenterology Journal, volume 10, issue 1, pages 93-103
Endoscopic direct clipping versus indirect clipping for colonic diverticular bleeding: A large multicenter cohort study
Takaaki Kishino
1
,
Naoyoshi Nagata
2, 3
,
Katsumasa Kobayashi
4
,
Atsushi Yamauchi
5
,
Atsuo Yamada
6
,
Jun Omori
7
,
Takashi Ikeya
8
,
Taiki Aoyama
9
,
Naoyuki Tominaga
10
,
Yoshinori Sato
11
,
Naoki Ishii
12
,
Tsunaki Sawada
13
,
Masaki Murata
14
,
Akinari Takao
15
,
Kazuhiro Mizukami
16
,
Ken Kinjo
17
,
Shunji Fujimori
18
,
Takahiro Uotani
19
,
MINORU FUJITA
20
,
Hiroki Sato
21
,
Sho Suzuki
22
,
Toshiaki Narasaka
23, 24
,
Junnosuke Hayasaka
25
,
Tomohiro Funabiki
26, 27
,
Yuzuru Kinjo
28
,
Akira Mizuki
29
,
Shu Kiyotoki
30
,
Tatsuya Mikami
31
,
Ryosuke Gushima
32
,
Hiroyuki Fujii
33
,
Yuta Fuyuno
34
,
Naohiko Gunji
35
,
Yosuke Toya
36
,
Kazuyuki Narimatsu
37
,
Noriaki Manabe
38
,
Koji Nagaike
39
,
Tetsu Kinjo
40
,
Yorinobu Sumida
41
,
Sadahiro Funakoshi
42
,
Kana Kawagishi
43
,
Tamotsu Matsuhashi
44
,
Yuga Komaki
45
,
Kuniko Miki
2
,
Kazuhiro Watanabe
3
,
Mitsuru Kaise
7
1
Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology Center for Digestive and Liver Diseases Nara City Hospital Nara Japan
|
4
Department of gastroenterology Tokyo Metropolitan Bokutoh Hospital Tokyo Japan
|
9
Department of Gastroenterology Hiroshima City Asa Citizens Hospital Hiroshima Japan
|
10
Department of Gastroenterology Saga Medical Center Koseikan Saga Japan
|
12
Department of Gastroenterology Tokyo Shinagawa Hospital Tokyo Japan
|
19
Department of Gastroenterology Japanese Red Cross Shizuoka Hospital Shizuoka Japan
|
27
Emergency and Critical Care Center Saiseikai Yokohama Tobu Hospital Kanagawa Yokohama Japan
|
28
Department of Gastroenterology Naha City Hospital Naha Okinawa Japan
|
29
Department of Internal Medicine Tokyo Saiseikai Central Hospital Tokyo Japan
|
30
Department of Gastroenterology Shuto General Hospital Yanai Yamaguchi Japan
|
33
Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology National Hospital Organization Fukuokahigashi Medical Center Fukuoka Japan
|
39
Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology Suita Municipal Hospital Osaka Japan
|
41
Department of Gastroenterology National Hospital Organization Kyushu Medical Center Fukuoka Japan
|
43
Publication type: Journal Article
Publication date: 2022-01-12
scimago Q1
SJR: 1.612
CiteScore: 10.5
Impact factor: 5.8
ISSN: 20506406, 20506414
PubMed ID:
35020977
Oncology
Gastroenterology
Abstract
Direct and indirect clipping treatments are used worldwide to treat colonic diverticular bleeding (CDB), but their effectiveness has not been examined in multicenter studies with more than 100 cases.We sought to determine the short- and long-term effectiveness of direct versus indirect clipping for CDB in a nationwide cohort.We studied 1041 patients with CDB who underwent direct clipping (n = 360) or indirect clipping (n = 681) at 49 hospitals across Japan (CODE BLUE-J Study).Multivariate analysis adjusted for age, sex, and important confounding factors revealed that, compared with indirect clipping, direct clipping was independently associated with reduced risk of early rebleeding (<30 days; adjusted odds ratio [AOR] 0.592, p = 0.002), late rebleeding (<1 year; AOR 0.707, p = 0.018), and blood transfusion requirement (AOR 0.741, p = 0.047). No significant difference in initial hemostasis rates was observed between the two groups. Propensity-score matching to balance baseline characteristics also showed significant reductions in the early and late rebleeding rates with direct clipping. In subgroup analysis, direct clipping was associated with significantly lower rates of early and late rebleeding and blood transfusion need in cases of stigmata of recent hemorrhage with non-active bleeding on colonoscopy, right-sided diverticula, and early colonoscopy, but not with active bleeding on colonoscopy, left-sided diverticula, or elective colonoscopy.Our large nationwide study highlights the use of direct clipping for CDB treatment whenever possible. Differences in bleeding pattern and colonic location can also be considered when deciding which clipping options to use.
Nothing found, try to update filter.
Nagata N., Kobayashi K., Yamauchi A., Yamada A., Omori J., Ikeya T., Aoyama T., Tominaga N., Sato Y., Kishino T., Ishii N., Sawada T., Murata M., Takao A., Mizukami K., et. al.
Kobayashi K., Furumoto Y., Akutsu D., Matsuoka M., Nozaka T., Asano T., Fujiki K., Gosho M., Narasaka T., Mizokami Y.
Are you a researcher?
Create a profile to get free access to personal recommendations for colleagues and new articles.