Prevalence of problematic smartphone usage and associated mental health outcomes amongst children and young people: a systematic review, meta-analysis and GRADE of the evidence
Background
Over the past decade, smartphone use has become widespread amongst today’s children and young people (CYP) which parallels increases in poor mental health in this group. Simultaneously, media concern abounds about the existence of ‘smartphone addiction’ or problematic smartphone use. There has been much recent research concerning the prevalence of problematic smartphone use is in children and young people who use smartphones, and how this syndrome relates to mental health outcomes, but this has not been synthesized and critically evaluated.
Aims
To conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis to examine the prevalence of PSU and quantify the association with mental health harms.
Methods
A search strategy using Medical Subject Headings was developed and adapted for eight databases between January 1, 1st 2011 to October 15th 2017. No language restriction was applied. Of 924 studies identified, 41 were included in this review, three of which were cohort studies and 38 were cross sectional studies. The mental health outcomes were self-reported: depression; anxiety; stress; poor sleep quality; and decreased educational attainment, which were synthesized according to an a priori protocol.
Results
The studies included 41,871 CYP, and 55% were female. The median prevalence of PSU amongst CYP was 23.3% (14.0–31.2%). PSU was associated with an increased odds of depression (OR = 3.17;95%CI 2.30–4.37;I2 = 78%); increased anxiety (OR = 3.05 95%CI 2.64–3.53;I2 = 0%); higher perceived stress (OR = 1.86;95%CI 1.24–2.77;I2 = 65%); and poorer sleep quality (OR = 2.60; 95%CI; 1.39–4.85, I2 = 78%).
Conclusions
PSU was reported in approximately one in every four CYP and accompanied by an increased odds of poorer mental health. PSU is an evolving public health concern that requires greater study to determine the boundary between helpful and harmful technology use. Policy guidance is needed to outline harm reduction strategies.
Top-30
Journals
|
5
10
15
20
|
|
|
Frontiers in Psychiatry
20 publications, 4.77%
|
|
|
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
17 publications, 4.06%
|
|
|
Frontiers in Psychology
15 publications, 3.58%
|
|
|
PLoS ONE
12 publications, 2.86%
|
|
|
Frontiers in Public Health
10 publications, 2.39%
|
|
|
Current Psychology
10 publications, 2.39%
|
|
|
Addictive Behaviors
10 publications, 2.39%
|
|
|
BMC Psychiatry
9 publications, 2.15%
|
|
|
International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction
8 publications, 1.91%
|
|
|
Computers in Human Behavior
8 publications, 1.91%
|
|
|
Journal of Medical Internet Research
6 publications, 1.43%
|
|
|
Journal of Affective Disorders
6 publications, 1.43%
|
|
|
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
6 publications, 1.43%
|
|
|
Cureus
6 publications, 1.43%
|
|
|
JMIR Formative Research
5 publications, 1.19%
|
|
|
Children
5 publications, 1.19%
|
|
|
Scientific Reports
5 publications, 1.19%
|
|
|
International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology
4 publications, 0.95%
|
|
|
BMC psychology
4 publications, 0.95%
|
|
|
Computers in Human Behavior Reports
4 publications, 0.95%
|
|
|
Behaviour and Information Technology
4 publications, 0.95%
|
|
|
Sustainability
3 publications, 0.72%
|
|
|
Journal of Adolescence
3 publications, 0.72%
|
|
|
Healthcare
3 publications, 0.72%
|
|
|
Comprehensive Psychiatry
3 publications, 0.72%
|
|
|
Digital Health
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
International Journal of Social Psychiatry
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Education and Information Technologies
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Pediatric Research
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
5
10
15
20
|
Publishers
|
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
|
|
|
Springer Nature
81 publications, 19.33%
|
|
|
Elsevier
62 publications, 14.8%
|
|
|
Frontiers Media S.A.
48 publications, 11.46%
|
|
|
MDPI
42 publications, 10.02%
|
|
|
Taylor & Francis
36 publications, 8.59%
|
|
|
Wiley
27 publications, 6.44%
|
|
|
JMIR Publications
21 publications, 5.01%
|
|
|
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
13 publications, 3.1%
|
|
|
SAGE
11 publications, 2.63%
|
|
|
Emerald
6 publications, 1.43%
|
|
|
BMJ
5 publications, 1.19%
|
|
|
Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health)
5 publications, 1.19%
|
|
|
Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
5 publications, 1.19%
|
|
|
IGI Global
4 publications, 0.95%
|
|
|
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
3 publications, 0.72%
|
|
|
Oxford University Press
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Cambridge University Press
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Walter de Gruyter
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
American Medical Association (AMA)
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Georg Thieme Verlag KG
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Masaryk University Press
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Mary Ann Liebert
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Royal College of Psychiatrists
2 publications, 0.48%
|
|
|
Vicenza Pediatria Medica E Chirurgica
1 publication, 0.24%
|
|
|
SciELO
1 publication, 0.24%
|
|
|
Korean Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
1 publication, 0.24%
|
|
|
Mark Allen Group
1 publication, 0.24%
|
|
|
Nevsehir Haci Bektas Veli Universitesi SBE Dergisi
1 publication, 0.24%
|
|
|
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
|
- We do not take into account publications without a DOI.
- Statistics recalculated weekly.